After several extensive tests on both the eLuxury and Tuft and Needle mattresses, I have come to the conclusion that eLuxury is simply the better choice. These mattresses are very similar in a lot of ways. They both have a slightly firmer feel at a 7 out of 10, they both float sleepers on top of the foam, they both sleep cool, they both are 10″, they both are built from 2 layers of foam, and they are both designed with a minimalist feel. 

That said, at the end of the day, eLuxury’s mattress simply does everything Tuft and Needle does…except better. It uses a true visco elastic memory foam instead of a basic polyfoam. Additionally, the top foam layer is more dense at 3.0 PCF vs. Tuft & Needle’s 2.9 PCF. Increased density will result in better durability and longevity. Lastly, and most important, eLuxury is simply cheaper by a notable margin. Tuft & Needle’s Queen is $600, while eLuxury comes in at $463 (with promo code SLEEPOPOLIS).

Bottom line…eLuxury is using better materials, has a similar feel, and is $136 cheaper. If you like the slightly firmer feel this one is a no-brainer. 

I would recommend eLuxury to sleepers who:

-Want a slightly firmer feel – coming in at a 7 out of 10 on the firmness scale, the eLuxury mattress is a great bed for those sleepers who want minimal sinkage and hug and a slightly firmer feel.

-Want minimal sinkage + good cooling – as a slightly firmer mattress, minimal sinkage and hug occurs while lying on this mattress. In a normal lying position (on my back) I saw 0.75-1″ of sinkage. If you’re looking to avoid the enveloped or stuck feeling, this is a great option. Additionally, the floating feeling that the mattress creates allows the mattress to breathe more easily, keeping the sleeping surface cool.

-Want to save some money  – the eLuxury mattress is offered at a reasonable price point for the quality of this mattress. There are no special bells and whistles about this mattress, however, it simply gets the job done. At $136 cheaper than Tuft & Needle (in the Queen size) it truly is an incredible deal.

-Want to buy from an established company  – eLuxury has been producing and selling bedding products online for 5 years now. With an average customer review of 4.87, it is safe to say the eLuxury prides themselves on excellent customer service from beginning to end.