We’ve come to the end of this comparison and we’re down to the big final question, which mattress is better, eLuxury or Casper? This was one of the harder comparisons I’ve done recently. If we look purely at performance, it’s a much closer contest. Both eLuxury and Casper perform at an above average level and provide good support, cooling, and comfort. The similar construction, materials, and design of these two mattress creates a similar level of performance and even feel to a certain degree.

There are many similarities between these two mattresses. However, there are really only two major comparison points that ultimately matter in this contest.

• Deep compression support – if you’re a heavier sleeper the Casper is unlikely to be a great fit, it simply doesn’t have great deep compression support and doesn’t do a great job of comfortably supporting heavier sleepers. eLuxury isn’t a miracle worker in this area, but it does provide a considerabe step up over Casper in my opinion. The 3.0? layer of memory foam in eLuxury is simply able to better relieve pressure and create better support for both light and heavier sleepers. Casper is spec’d to support up to 250 pounds per side, eLuxury is spec’d to support up to 400 pounds.
• Price – this one is perhaps the most telling. The Queen Casper is $850. The Queen eLuxury is $545. The material components and performance on both the Casper and eLuxury is very similar, so why is the Casper $305 more? I don’t believe the Casper is worth the extra cost vs. the eLuxury.

The bottom line – when you get right down to the bottom line the material quality and performance between these two mattresses is very similar. The price, however, is not. I’m hard pressed to come up with a single reason for why the Casper would be worth the extra $305. When you also factor in the deep compression support difference it’s even more of a no brainer in my opinion. For these reasons, the eLuxury mattress is the winner of this mattress battle.